Bungling

Gross bungling of primary sources

  • interpreting them in crazy ways. Eg. Sheldon Pollock [YT17]

Severe lack of contextual knowledge

  • leading to crazy (yet vehement) extrapolations.
  • The typical indologist’s evaluation of (even modern, let alone ancient) India can be silly, condescending and demeaning? Just take this recent example.

“Intellectual yet idiot” phenomenon